The Career-Altering Question: Generalist or Specialist?

Is it better to be a generalist or a specialist at work? You’ll face this choice about six to ten years into your career. Should you broaden your skills or narrow your focus?

Generalists are versatile professionals with moderate experience across various fields. They excel in roles like management and project coordination, allowing them to see the big picture. Their adaptability opens diverse job opportunities and helps build a vast network. In fast-paced environments, generalists are invaluable.

On the other hand, specialists dive deep into a particular area. They acquire expertise that surpasses most others, focusing intensely on their topics. This depth of knowledge earns them recognition and demand. Specialists often enjoy higher salaries and are crucial for organizations requiring specific skills.

David Epstein’s Range: Why Generalists Triumph in a Specialized World (2019,) argues that generalists thrive long-term due to their broad skill set, which enhances adaptability. Specialists, however, contend that deep knowledge is necessary for driving progress. In a strong workplace, both roles are essential. Generalists rely on specialists, and specialists benefit from generalists. Together, they effectively solve problems.

Ultimately, your choice depends on your career goals. Decide what aligns with your strengths and aspirations. A balanced approach can be effective: start as a generalist, as most do at the beginning, exploring your industry without knowing what you don’t know. This exploration helps identify your interests and strengths. By six to ten years in, refine your focus and zero in on a path that resonates with your passions. After that, specialize in what truly inspires you. However, as you advance in a company, you may need to shift back to generalism, as managing multiple domains often requires this flexibility.