Rules—like laws—exist to civilize chaos. In the service industry, they promise fairness and consistency—noble aims, until they ossify into dogma. When employees are reduced to rule-spouting mannequins, the result isn’t order but inertia. A workforce trained to obey rather than think will reliably deliver less than it could, while the system smugly applauds its own mediocrity.
Some rules deserve reverence. Call them red zone: safety, legality, ethics. These are nonnegotiable. But most rules aren’t red zone. They’re yellow. And yellow rules, when treated as sacred, become absurd. They’re guidelines, not commandments. They exist to be interpreted—not enforced with the zeal of a customs officer confiscating a banana.
Discretion isn’t anarchy. It demands boundaries—but also trust. Define what staff can spend, compromise, accommodate, decide, and deviate from. Give them the rationale behind the rule, not just the regulation. Teach them to think, not to flinch.
Consider the Ritz-Carlton. Every employee—from housekeeper to concierge—is authorized to spend up to $2,000 per guest, per incident, without managerial approval, to resolve a problem or elevate an experience. It sounds extravagant—and admittedly, most issues won’t come close to needing a four-figure remedy. But that’s not the point. The policy isn’t about the literal dollar amount. It’s about the psychological effect of front-loading trust. The generous limit signals deep belief in the employee’s judgment. It liberates staff to act decisively and without hesitation.
That kind of empowerment transforms service into ownership. It fuels morale, initiative, and personal investment in outcomes. For guests, it delivers not just swift resolutions—but memorable gestures. These are moments that forge lasting emotional loyalty. They’re not indulgences. Ritz sees them as smart calculations—acts of discretionary judgment with an eye toward the lifetime value of a loyal customer. Ritz-Carlton knows it can’t buy loyalty with rules, but it can earn it with discretion.
Idea for Impact: Good employees should be allowed to break good rules
Fear is the enemy of judgment. A workforce trained to avoid mistakes will never achieve excellence. The best service isn’t delivered by smiling bureaucrats. It’s delivered by people trusted to use their brains. A rule is only as good as the judgment behind its use.
Leave a Reply